[Blackstudies-l] Hilary Beckles: Imagining Post-IMF Caribbean Economy

Maria Lima lima at geneseo.edu
Sun Nov 19 11:46:05 EST 2017

ivetteromero posted: " Here is a commentary on Caribbean economy by Sir
Hilary Beckles, vice-chancellor of the University of the West Indies. He
writes, “A wholistic Caribbean development model, post-IMF, has to be
imagined as we are currently spinning in mud and going nowher"
Respond to this post by replying above this line
New post on *Repeating Islands*
<http://repeatingislands.com/author/ivetteromero/> Hilary Beckles:
Imagining Post-IMF Caribbean Economy
ivetteromero <http://repeatingislands.com/author/ivetteromero/>

*[image: beck.Untitled]*

*Here is a commentary on Caribbean economy by Sir Hilary Beckles,
vice-chancellor of the University of the West Indies. He writes, “A
wholistic Caribbean development model, post-IMF, has to be imagined as we
are currently spinning in mud and going nowhere very fast.” Read full
article at the Jamaica Gleaner

Circumstances are rapidly maturing that are demanding our conception of the
need for both a new-style IMF and a 21st-century post-IMF Caribbean economy.

The elements of the regional dialogue are coming together. They might
constitute at this time a blurred image of an alternative Caribbean
economy, but they are calling attention to the growing regional interest in
a serious focus upon economic sustainability and resilience, and nation
building - phase two.

The growth in social and economic inequality across the region in recent
decades under IMF tutelage has been identified as a major concern. The
recent UNDP Caribbean Economic Report tells the starkest version of the
story. It shows that while approved fiscal and financial arguments, and
corresponding analytic tools, can explain the significant upward social
mobility of the immediate post-independence, pre-IMF period, we seem
impotent to prevent, and understand, the consequences of the daily descent
into poverty from the middle class since the normalisation and
domestication of the IMF.

The Caribbean is not only experiencing the systemic erosion of earlier
social mobility gains, but the eruption of a new mental construct in which
more citizens, seized in the grip of economic decline, are focused upon
'getting out' and 'getting even' with the nation.

Citizen versus State is emerging as a primary political feature of the
IMF-ruled Caribbean. More citizens are feeling abandoned by the state-IMF
alliance and consider it, in some places, an opposition force. We are
seeing this anti-nation sentiment playing out in our cricket culture, and
the deepening conflictual nature of urban living.

The sustainability of the nation seems imperilled without either violent
repression or IMF reinforcements. This circumstance called into question
the role of the IMF in the future of Caribbean democracy. For sure, the
public perceives that IMF official thinking and tutelage place it on the
battlefront where the social effects of its fiscals are fiercely felt.
Either way we look at it, IMF economics, while desired and accepted for
macro stability, continues to problematise how the propertyless majority is
marginalised in the economy, they are keenly ready to kick-start.

In effect, then, while we have effectively put in place IMF-inspired
'economic czars' to drive the economic growth agenda, a strategy to be
publicly supported, we are also desperately in need of 'social czars' to
keep the bottom from dropping out of democracy ideal. To prevent this, the
IMF top-down fiscal focus should be accompanied by an indigenous 'middle
out' and 'bottom-up' economic vision that sees social growth and a
prerequisite for, rather than a consequence of, economic growth.

Where will the new entrepreneurship come from to stabilise our economies
and lay the foundations for innovative, competitive industry drivers in the
next two decades? The elite economy will continue to hold its own, and this
is necessary to keep structures and instructions viable. However, the
global lessons of recent decades show that the middle and bottom have
greater creative energy for the economic uplift that is required.

In addition to this, there is the monumental matter of the IMF not wishing
to bend its ear to hear of the colonial mess the region has inherited from
EUROPEAN wealth extractive colonialism. Nor does it wish to hear of the
reparatory role these developed countries have a moral and legal duty to
play in the enormous cleaning up task that has overwhelmed the region.

The IMF proceed on the basis that Caribbean economies began in 1962 when
Jamaica led the path to independence. It does not wish to know of inherited
structures and values. As the fiscal and financial voice of these developed
nations, it might not be able to unblinker itself. It is our duty to tell
it over and over again that the interface of history and economics has
dealt the region an awful hand. And, despite our noblest efforts, cleaning
up of colonial debris is overwhelming us. A wholistic Caribbean development
model, post-IMF, has to be imagined as we are currently spinning in mud and
going nowhere very fast. There is room in future thinking for a revised
21st-century IMF.

Everywhere in the Caribbean is now at risk on account of current IMF
development thinking. The region sought to convert its colonials into
citizens by spending on health, education, urban development, that is,
cleaning up the colonial mess they did not create. The IMF demands that
such entitlements are beyond its means, and has no policy framework to
facilitate social growth and economic growth simultaneously. But should a
new, revised, 21st-century IMF not be an advocate for a Marshall plan for
the postcolonial Caribbean? Should a new, more relevant IMF not be a
facilitator of a reparatory approach to economic growth with social growth?

The IMF, as we know it today, might consider itself fit for purpose, but
the truth says something more - that by failing to fathom the real depth of
the inherited Caribbean economic problem, it is at best a Band-Aid
operation rather than a growth generator. As the young people would put it,
"I am just saying!"

*Professor Sir Hilary Beckles is vice-chancellor of the University of the
West Indies. Email feedback to columns at gleanerjm.com
<columns at gleanerjm.com>.*


*ivetteromero <http://repeatingislands.com/author/ivetteromero/>* |
November 19, 2017 at 11:20 am | Tags: Caribbean economy
<http://repeatingislands.com/tag/caribbean-economy/>, Sir Hilary Beckles
<http://repeatingislands.com/tag/sir-hilary-beckles/> | Categories: News
<http://repeatingislands.com/category/news/> | URL: https://wp.me/psnTa-yMZ

   See all comments

to no longer receive posts from Repeating Islands.
Change your email settings at Manage Subscriptions

*Trouble clicking?* Copy and paste this URL into your browser:
Thanks for flying with WordPress.com <https://wordpress.com>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.geneseo.edu/pipermail/blackstudies-l/attachments/20171119/0184d72e/attachment-0001.html>

More information about the Blackstudies-l mailing list